Yakkstr

Progressives: Humanitarians?

Even though they have done a pretty good job convincing the masses that they(Progressives) are the humanitarians among us, their own words, actions, and history should prove that notion is completely false.

In fact, one action, one massive action should speak volumes to all who read this.

On January 1st, 1972, EPA Administrator William Ruckelshaus became the Hitler of our time, when against the will of the scientific community, he unilaterally banned the use of DDT to combat malaria, and hence sentenced 100's of millions to death, misery, and eternal poverty.

Here may be some insight as to why.

As recently as 2005, 500 million people around the world (approximately one-twelfth of the earth’s population) were contracting malaria on an annual basis; and each year, 2 to 3 million of them died as a result. Since the 1972 U.S. ban on DDT, more than 50 million people—about 90 percent of whom resided in sub-Saharan Africa, and most of whom were children younger than five—have died of malaria.

And here is the justification.

former (1969-1985) Sierra Club director Michael McCloskey said (in 1971) that his organization “wants a ban on pesticides, even in countries where DDT has kept malaria under control ... [because by] using DDT, we reduce mortality rates in underdeveloped countries without the consideration of how to support the increase in populations.”

In a similar spirit, Club of Rome director Alexander King wrote in 1990: “My chief quarrel with DDT in hindsight is that it greatly added to the population problem.”

source

report |
sean_renaud said over 2 years ago ...

There is tons of evidence that DDT is harmful! It causes premature birth for one. Which still doesn't address your core point which is an attempt to claim the EPA does more harm than good. I don't worry about my drinking water though, do you? Pollution is way down in the US. We know smog kills. we know that rivers can catch fire. we know that fish can be mutated and we know it can taint your food supply, we know your tap water can catch fire too.. So there is a lot of stuff that's in play here, you can't just pick one thing out and claim that this is proof and ignore everything around it.

d6fer said over 2 years ago ...

reck....in this case yes....in a passive aggressive sort of way.

sean....I would take premature birth over premature death anyday.

sean_renaud said over 2 years ago ...

So would I. But I wouldn't choose unsafe drinking water for my country over death in another country. I'm American first, and I can't help anybody else if I can't help myself. I'd love to start setting up water purification in Mexico, Africa, India and South America. I'd love to start getting those people fed, currently we have a hard enough time convincing people that Americans are entitled to food and shelter however so until we can get past that hurdle those people get to suffer.

reckoner said over 2 years ago ...

really d6? Hitler intended to kill jews. The person banning DDT did not intend to kill anyone, and it's questionable whether you can even assign responsibility for malaria deaths to that person.

If a conservative repeals some clean air law, and 1 more million people die of asthma, are they responsible for those deaths?

d6fer said over 2 years ago ...

Do progressive believe the Earth is over populated?

sean_renaud said over 2 years ago ...

I'm sure there are people who think that, but nobody with any real power. It's like asking do Conservatives think the poor deserve to die? Sure there are social darwinists out there but really whenever pressed nobody seems to actually scream that we need to stop people from eating or kick them out of the emergency room. IF you use real words instead of code words like entitled people don't think that nor believe that.

d6fer said over 2 years ago ...

I pointed out two of them in the post that had direct involvement.

sean_renaud said over 2 years ago ...

Pretty sure those folks are dead and still a minority. Like I said I could point out all sorts of nasty conservatives but I don't, when avoidable, extreme examples. I use examples that can be replicated and pointed to. Which congressman or senator do you think believes that? Which prominent figure? Someone who can be pointed to and said, "why do you accept this guy?"

Join our friendly Yakkstr community in 1 Easy Step
  • Meet Like Minded People
  • Share your thoughts with others who share your interests
  • No assholes to deal with, we keep them out
Join Now by writing your first comment below


Related Posts
Extra Credit: Broken Politics Pt.2
Last week I posted Extra Credit: Broken Politics really as a bit of a conversation starter. This week the subject focuses primarily on finding ways to get the money out of politi
5 comments
last by sean_renaud about 1 year ago
Crisis management
In 2011 our elected representatives were unable to make a decision on the budget because of their ideology so they created a program called sequester whereby each federal department would be cut by a certain percentage each year to bring the national de
3 comments
last by alienated about 1 year ago
The Knock Out Game
And more urban myths brought to you by Conservatives and completely situational outrage and conditional ethics. (I'd be a lot more supporting of their point of view if they'd say things like “that's what I would do” I have to admit C
7 comments
last by sean_renaud about 1 year ago
The war within
We have not pre-emptively invaded a third world country that we are superior to militarily in 12 years and maybe our elected official are getting a little antsy, becaue in the last budget agreement they declared war on the less fortunate and those witho
6 comments
last by truthserum41 about 1 year ago
Guns don't kill people, Democratic Socialists do.
An undeniable pattern has continued to emerge in light of mass shootings, despite the media’s attempt to avoid connecting the dots. In the wake of recent high-profile shootings, the media can almost immediately be seen attempting to link derang
24 comments Last Page
last by sean_renaud about 1 year ago

Remember me

New? Sign up here.
d6fer commented 1 day ago on
King Abdullah is dead
I never read the article I saw on that, but the picture and headlines gave me just a little more respect for the woman.....bout damn read the rest
d6fer commented 1 day ago on
Indiana to open state run news outlet
I guess it wouldn't really be any different than it is now. At least Republicans would have a little more favorable media now and read the rest
d6fer commented 2 days ago on
Why do teens smoke?
I don't understand the attraction to something that at first experience makes you sick. Not to mention the common knowledge of what it does to your read the rest
d6fer commented 2 days ago on
Indiana to open state run news outlet
No you can't do these kinds of things even with the best of intentions. You never know who will have control next......Patriot act read the rest
d6fer commented 2 days ago on
King Abdullah is dead
Michelle has bigger balls than Barry does.....she refused to read the rest
d6fer commented 5 days ago on
Living Fossil Caught
When i was working in Dutch Harbor Alaska many years ago an eel of some sort came in with a boatload of crab. I think it was a wolf eel. I remember it being about the ugliest thing I had ever read the rest
d6fer commented 5 days ago on
King Abdullah is dead
I hear the new King has dementia. We'll see how that read the rest
d6fer commented 8 days ago on
2015 State of the Union
Actually you used to say that black people can't be racist because they are not in a position of read the rest
d6fer commented 8 days ago on
Could we cause a major quake?
So you're saying that the pressure from modern fracking is somehow going to be worse than the explosives and nukes they once used? Only a moron would believe read the rest
d6fer commented 9 days ago on
Could we cause a major quake?
wombie.....the question is : Who is "they"? There are always plenty of "theys" around to substantiate whatever someone wants them read the rest