Yakkstr

The government can't make mandates!

George Washington would like a word with you Conservatives.

If the Constitution was supposed to directly or like privacy, it was simply implied somehow, that the government doesn't have the right to force you to buy things then why did the first President of the United Staes put out a mandate for Health Insurance? Granted it was closer to car insurance today since it was limited to a single profession, being a seaman (heh heh heh), but it was a government issued mandate nontheless. Not a state mandate, a Federal one.

Some people have asked if the government has the power to make you buy health insurance, what's next, brocoli? Funny thing about that two years after forcing captains to buy insurance President Washington made a mandate that every able bodied man own a fire arm. So if we take George Washington and the other Founding Fathers as a bell weather it's clear. If there is enough proof you need to buy brocoli the Founders didn't have any problem forcing you to do it.

That whole argument of these aren't the principles this country was founded on just flew out the window. Even the Framers were smart enough to know the simple truth. Sometimes the government needs to step in and tell people what to do because left to their own devices they'll make poor decisions. I highly doubt (though I'm no historian) that George Washington and John Adams (who signed an individual mandate on seamen [heh heh]) to do their friends in the insurance companies a favors. They did it because there was a need.

report |
reckoner said about 1 year ago ...

i'm curious what kind of reply we'll see from the righties. I'm guessing it will be crickets :)

sean_renaud said about 1 year ago ...

Yeah but now I've got something to link the next time someone brings it up.

d6fer said about 1 year ago ...

Interesting.....I wonder why he didn't link to supporting documents?

reckoner said about 1 year ago ...

here is one

sean_renaud said about 1 year ago ...

Here's a PDF for "An act for sick and disable seamen.

I'll work on tracking down the other last one.

sean_renaud said about 1 year ago ...

Section 8 Of the "An act for the regulatin of seamen [heh heh] in the merchant services."

So that's all three.

reckoner said about 1 year ago ...

crickets

d6fer said about 1 year ago ...

I have a hard time following legal speak....let alone colonial legal speak....are they referring to military?

sean_renaud said about 1 year ago ...

Which link?

sean_renaud said 12 months ago ...

Chirp fucking chirp.

Join our friendly Yakkstr community in 1 Easy Step
  • Meet Like Minded People
  • Share your thoughts with others who share your interests
  • No assholes to deal with, we keep them out
Join Now by writing your first comment below


Related Posts
I hate semantics
Encase you weren't paying attention the Supreme Court hearings over Obamacare or the Affortable Care
14 comments
last by reckoner about 1 year ago

Remember me

New? Sign up here.
sean_renaud commented about 3 hours ago on
Jon Stewart on the current crop of scandals
Fine, find *someone* who said it. While *you* claimed Obama said it I'll let you move the goal posts. Find me someone who said it with the only qualification being Micheal Moore and Rachel Maddow don't count. I bet you I can find people on yourside, read the rest
sean_renaud commented about 4 hours ago on
Jon Stewart on the current crop of scandals
Find the quote where he said it. The reason you don't have time is ultimately because you are wrong and you can't win because you're wrong. I constantly quote articles and double check things. You believe what you're told and never even stop to ask read the rest
sean_renaud commented about 4 hours ago on
ADHD in France
I don't know everything about you. I know enough to know that a system that isn't focused on cutting prices isn't one you're likely to emulate. I know enough to know that I've pointed out dozens of times the advantages of both the Asian and European read the rest
sean_renaud commented about 4 hours ago on
Jon Stewart on the current crop of scandals
No. It should be skyrocketing with all the "monopoly" money we are printing. Not that we're exactly doing that and I've explained it to you on a level that a 6 year old should be able to comprehend. But if your theory of inflation was correct this read the rest
sean_renaud commented about 5 hours ago on
ADHD in France
I get out plenty, and hell I just stopped being a kid and people have been claiming things that aren't true since I was still in school. Shit like sports with no scores and no winners or losers. Children that aren't diciplined by their parents. It's read the rest
sean_renaud commented about 7 hours ago on
The Return Of Nixon Politics
He didn't lie about taxes. At the worst he misled stupid people but that's really a semantic argument. What legislation did he sign without 48 hours (at least) of public scrutiny?. He didn't lie about Bengazi. He didn't tell the American people it read the rest
sean_renaud commented about 7 hours ago on
Waterboarding Saved Lives
You're question doesn't have a point. It's unlikely we'll ever find ourselves in a position where torture saves lives and it's a fact that torture creates terrorists and well accepted that *not* torturing them saves lives. The only reason you don't read the rest
sean_renaud commented about 7 hours ago on
If They Did Nothing Wrong, Why Hide?
They aren't hiding anything. There is nothing to hide. But please, please, please impeach Obama. Pretty read the rest
sean_renaud commented about 18 hours ago on
ADHD in France
The video is neat, it kinda deserves it's own post honestly. Where in the eleven hells is it considered child abuse to spank children? Or say no to them? It's certainly not America. I don't think I've ever met this mythical child who doesn't get read the rest
sean_renaud commented 1 day ago on
Who remembers when Bush lied about Saddam being connected to Al Qaeda?
You're not a libertarian. You're a Teahadist. A libertarian would support gay marriage and abortion because they are both personal choices and something the *big government* has no business being a part of. You're ashamed of your party which is read the rest